Thanks to Leo's topic...

Which one? I'd go for 2. It was perfect. The ships... the missions. The sheer look. Three's on-foot sections were horrible, and a lot of things were ridiculously annoying. (Speeder bike, dantooine?)
1, was nice. But a little... unpolished. I know it was an N64 game, but it didn't have quite the look.

Which is why 2. It looked amazing, it looked... wow.

And the missions. YUM! Blowing up BOTH death stars, taking down star destroyers! THE BATTLE OF ENDOR!!

My lord.
It rocked.

I voted the first, the only one I've played a lot, but mainly for the nostalgic feel.